Sometime this Thursday, at a whole lot of Thanksgiving tables, somebody is going to tap a glass and ask everyone to name one thing they’re thankful for before the turkey gets cold. (There’s always one uncle who says “pie” and thinks he’s hilarious.) Then it goes around the table: family, health, a job, the grandkids, the folks who couldn’t make it this year. It’s a sweet tradition, and I’m all for it. But have you ever noticed that just about everything on that list is something we’ve already got in our hands?
That’s what thankfulness usually looks like. Gratitude is the ultimate emotion of thanksgiving, and I don’t just mean Thanksgiving with a capital T. I mean being thankful, plain and simple, for what you have.
But I’ll be honest with you. After all these years of praying, preaching, and writing about prayer, I’ve recently been playing with an idea about gratitude that’s new to me, and I’m still working it out. Which might not be a bad thing to admit as this year’s Thanksgiving rolls around: There’s still something new and interesting to learn each year as we approach gratefulness.
Here’s the idea. If we’re going to pray believing, then the appropriate response after we pray is gratitude. Gratitude that we have received, in God’s timing, what we’ve asked for … before we ever see it show up. Now, this whole thing is a tightrope, so let’s walk it carefully.
This Isn’t Name It and Claim It
Let me say right up front what this post isn’t. I don’t want to lean into the whole name-it-and-claim-it, believe-it-and-receive-it, prosperity type of gospel. You know the one. Pray hard enough and believe big enough, and God has to hand over whatever you’ve got your eye on.
That isn’t the gospel, and it isn’t how God works. So if that’s what you’re bracing for, you can relax.
But We Can’t Ignore the Verses
Jesus said he came so that we “may have life, and have it to the full” (John 10:10), which is about as far from a grudging, half-hearted kind of faith as you can get. James tells us to ask God in faith without doubting, and he says the one who doubts “should not expect to receive anything from the Lord” (James 1:5–8). Jesus clearly said, “Ask and it will be given to you” (Matthew 7:7).
And in Mark 11:24, he goes a step further: “Whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours.” Did you catch the tense there? Believe that you HAVE received it. Not “will receive it someday, if you’re lucky.” I see nothing in any of those phrases, or any of those teachings, that says, “so long as you’re being reasonable.”
The Tightrope
So which is it? Is God sovereign, or is God obligated to deliver when we believe hard enough? Truth? I absolutely believe in the sovereignty of God.
God doesn’t owe us anything, and we can’t manipulate God into giving us everything we want. Or, for that matter, anything we want.
But the psalmist said God wants to give us the desires of our hearts, and look at how that verse starts: “Take delight in the LORD, and he will give you the desires of your heart” (Psalm 37:4). The desires grow out of delighting in him. And there’s a difference between the desires of our hearts and the desires of our brain, or our gimme-gimme attitude about God as the divine Santa Claus, or the Tooth Fairy. (Slip a request under the pillow, and there’s a new car in the driveway by morning? Not so much.)
We Don’t Always Get What We Ask For
Here’s where the tightrope gets wobbly. We don’t always get what we ask for, and Jesus himself is proof. When Jesus faced the cross, he asked for plan B: “Father, if it is possible, may this cup be taken from me” (Matthew 26:39). And apparently there wasn’t a plan B. You could say God didn’t answer that prayer, or you could say he did answer it, and the answer was, “No, this is how it is.”
Then there’s the time the disciples tried to set a little boy free, and they couldn’t pull it off. Jesus told them, “This kind can come out only by prayer” (Mark 9:29). And Garth Brooks built a whole country song around thanking God for “Unanswered Prayers.” Quite clearly, God has a different perspective than we have.
The Two Most Critical Words
So we don’t always get what we want … And Yet. Those words, And Yet, are two of the most critical words in our theology. God said, ask. God said, believe that we’re going to receive what we ask for.
Go back to the garden for a minute, since Jesus walked this exact tightrope in a single prayer. He asked for plan B out loud, no hedging. And then came the “yet”: “Yet not as I will, but as you will.” He didn’t skip the asking and jump straight to God’s will. He told the Father exactly what he wanted, and then he trusted him with the answer.
Now, I don’t know if prayers go unanswered, or we get a negative response, because we don’t have enough faith, or because we’re outside of God’s will, or what. I don’t. But I’m convinced of this much: We don’t wrestle enough with any of this.
Where We Get Stuck
I think we get stuck in three places. First, we often pray without the expectation our prayers are going to be answered in the way we’re praying. We say the words, and then we brace for the no.
Second, we forget to say thanks when those answers do come. The prayer gets answered, life moves on, and we never get around to the thank-you. (I suspect you’ll hear this sermon a lot over the next few days!)
And third, the one this whole post is about: We forget to say thanks, or to live within gratefulness, before the prayer is answered. We don’t act as if it’s already ours.
Maybe you’re thinking, “Isn’t it a little presumptuous to thank God for something he hasn’t given me yet?” Listen, that’s exactly what Mark 11:24 tells us to do. And here’s the sneaky part: We use God’s will as an excuse for our own doubts. We tack “if it be your will” onto the end of a prayer, and sometimes it’s real surrender … but I think most of the time it’s a safety net, so we never have to be disappointed.
Living Grateful Before the Answer Comes
So what does this look like on an ordinary Tuesday? Step one is always reviewing our requests through the lens of God’s will. Is this a desire of my heart that grows out of delighting in God, or is it just a desire of my brain? Is this a prayer, or a letter to Santa?
Second, check yourself for the opposite problem. If “God’s will” has become the place you hide so you never have to believe for anything, call it what it is.
Third, it’s time to wrestle – to really struggle with it. Say it out loud: “God, this is what I want.” Jesus did exactly that in the garden, and so can we.
Fourth, live as if God is answering those prayers in the positive. Thank him now, before you see it, as if it’s already yours. Which is to say, live that life of gratefulness.
So this Thursday, by all means, go around the table and give thanks for what’s already on your plate. Then try something new right alongside it. Give thanks for what you’ve asked God for and haven’t yet seen, and live this week as if it’s already yours.
For Folks Who Can’t Sit Still
One last thing, and I’ll keep it light. If sitting still long enough to pray has never been your strong suit, I wrote a book for folks like me (and maybe you’ll resonate). Prayer for People Who Can’t Sit Still offers ten different ways to pray for those who want to get into God’s presence but don’t have the contemplation gene. (Many of them work great with kids, too.)